The Pseudo-Scientific Resurgence: Why Modern Genetics Debunks Claims of Innate Racial Intelligence

The recent emergence of rhetoric linking national origin and race to innate intellectual capacity has sparked a significant debate within the global scientific community. At this year’s World Economic Forum in Davos, US President Donald Trump characterized Somali populations as having “low IQs,” a sentiment that mirrors public comments made by Donald Trump Jr. regarding Haitian migrants in 2024. These political declarations, which coincide with shifts in US federal policy regarding protected statuses for these specific migrant groups, are not isolated incidents. They represent a broader, orchestrated trend in Western political discourse: the attempt to legitimize “race science” and “race realism” as credible academic frameworks.
The Anatomy of a Scientific Mirage
The core argument used by proponents of these views—often termed hereditarianism—posits that genetic factors are the primary drivers of behavioral and intellectual differences between racial groups. This framework asserts that evolutionary pressures, such as migration patterns or climate adaptations, have resulted in distinct cognitive architectures for different human populations. However, mainstream evolutionary biology, genetics, and anthropology have thoroughly rejected these conclusions.
The foundational challenge to hereditarianism remains the work of evolutionary biologist Richard Lewontin, whose 1972 findings demonstrated that the vast majority of human genetic variation—roughly 85% to 90%—exists within any given local population rather than between them. Modern genomic sequencing has only served to solidify this consensus. While physical traits such as skin pigmentation, hair texture, or metabolic adaptations (such as lactose persistence) do vary geographically, they do not align with the broad, socially constructed categories of “race.” DNA analysis confirms that human populations have been in a state of constant flux and intermingling for millennia, rendering the concept of "pure bloodlines" genetically nonsensical.
Chronology of a Controversial Network
The persistence of these theories in the 21st century is not a result of new scientific breakthroughs, but rather the result of a persistent, well-funded infrastructure. The following timeline illustrates the evolution of this movement:

- 1930s: The Pioneer Fund is established by a US textile magnate to support research into eugenics and provide legal backing for segregationist causes.
- 1960s: Mankind Quarterly emerges as a primary venue for race-based research, effectively acting as a hub for those rejected by mainstream academia.
- 1990s–2000s: The Pioneer Fund continues to subsidize controversial research, maintaining links between academic figures and extremist ideological groups.
- 2010s: The "London Conferences on Intelligence" are held on the campus of University College London (UCL) without the university’s institutional knowledge, sparking an investigation after the nature of the content is revealed.
- 2024–2025: Public accusations of plagiarism against scholars such as the late Jason Arday by figures like Nathan Cofnas bring renewed attention to the underlying "race realism" network.
- 2026: Investigations into funding sources, including contributions from figures like Andrew Conru, reveal a complex web of financial support designed to provide a veneer of academic legitimacy to pseudoscientific work.
Methodological Failures in "National IQ" Data
A central pillar of the race-realist argument is the use of "national IQ" databases. These datasets have been widely criticized by the scientific community for severe methodological flaws. Critics point out that IQ tests are culturally situated; they often measure specific types of formal education and test-taking proficiency rather than raw intelligence.
When researchers attempt to aggregate these scores across disparate nations, they fail to account for massive disparities in educational access, nutrition, and environmental stability. Furthermore, studies have suggested that in some instances, researchers have engaged in "cherry-picking" data—intentionally selecting low-scoring samples from sub-Saharan Africa to artificially suppress the regional average. The "Flynn effect," which documents the steady rise of IQ scores globally throughout the 20th century, further undermines the hereditarian position. The speed of these increases—too rapid for genetic evolution—proves that environmental factors, such as improved healthcare and schooling, are the dominant forces in shaping cognitive performance.
The Social Brain and Evolutionary Reality
Mainstream evolutionary psychology posits that the primary driver of human cognitive development was not "cold weather" or specific racial selection pressures, but the necessity of managing complex social environments. Humans evolved to navigate intricate hierarchies, cooperate in child-rearing, and utilize cultural transmission to solve problems. This "social brain hypothesis" suggests that all human groups share the same fundamental cognitive toolkit.
The "cold winters theory"—a staple of race science that claims Northern populations evolved higher intelligence to survive harsh climates—is dismissed by mainstream anthropologists. They note that the migration out of Africa involved traversing diverse, challenging terrains, all of which required high levels of innovation and adaptive intelligence. There is no evidence that one specific environment produced a "superior" intellect; rather, human diversity is a testament to the species’ ability to adapt behaviorally to changing circumstances.
Academic Gatekeeping and the Future of Discourse
The presence of race science in academic journals is largely confined to a small subset of publications, such as Intelligence, which have been criticized for allowing ideological bias to override peer-review rigor. While some journals have attempted to clean up their editorial boards—such as the recent appointment of new editors at Elsevier’s Intelligence—the network has proven resilient.

By migrating to platforms like Aporia magazine and utilizing social media channels like X (formerly Twitter), proponents of these theories have bypassed traditional academic scrutiny. The intent is clearly to influence public opinion and policy rather than engage in scientific inquiry. The recent involvement of high-profile tech figures in funding these networks indicates a pivot toward using "academic" research to justify political stances on immigration, development, and social equality.
Implications for Society and Science
The implications of this resurgence are profound. By framing social and economic disparities as biological "inevitabilities," proponents of race science provide a pseudo-intellectual justification for dismantling social welfare programs and justifying discriminatory immigration policies. Historically, this type of rhetoric directly preceded the eugenics programs of the early 20th century, including the forced sterilizations in the United States and the atrocities of the Nazi regime.
Academic freedom is frequently cited as a defense for publishing these theories. However, the scientific method relies on the exclusion of demonstrably false, flawed, and biased work. When a body of research fails to align with the foundational principles of genetics and evolutionary biology, it ceases to be "scientific debate" and becomes a vehicle for propaganda.
The consensus remains clear: there is no biological basis for the hierarchy of races. As the global community navigates an increasingly polarized political landscape, the distinction between rigorous, evidence-based research and ideologically driven pseudoscience is more critical than ever. The challenge for academic institutions is to maintain a standard of excellence that prevents the hijacking of scientific platforms by those seeking to re-litigate the discarded, dangerous ideologies of the past.







