T-Mobile to remove data caps and expand access following New York settlement over affordable broadband violations

New York state officials have reached a legally binding settlement with T-Mobile, compelling the telecommunications giant to overhaul its low-income home Internet offerings. The agreement follows a formal investigation by the New York Office of the Attorney General (OAG), which concluded that the carrier had systematically undermined the state’s Affordable Broadband Act (ABA) by imposing restrictive data caps, throttling speeds, and deliberately obscuring information about the program from potential subscribers.
Under the terms of the settlement, T-Mobile must eliminate its 50 GB-per-month data cap for these specific plans, cease the practice of throttling speeds to 600 Kbps, and expand the availability of these affordable services to regions currently served by the company’s 4G infrastructure. The company is required to implement these sweeping changes within a 120-day window, ensuring that low-income households in New York receive the high-speed access promised by state law.
The Legislative Context: New York’s Affordable Broadband Act
The New York Affordable Broadband Act (ABA) was enacted to bridge the digital divide by mandating that Internet Service Providers (ISPs) with at least 20,000 customers in the state offer high-speed broadband to income-eligible households at controlled price points. Specifically, the law requires providers to offer plans at $15 per month for speeds of at least 25 Mbps, or $20 per month for speeds of at least 200 Mbps.
The law faced significant resistance from the telecommunications industry, leading to a protracted four-year legal battle. Major industry lobby groups, including CTIA—the wireless association representing T-Mobile, AT&T, and Verizon—challenged the statute on constitutional grounds, arguing that states lacked the authority to impose such pricing regulations. The conflict reached its conclusion in December 2024, when the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the industry’s challenge, allowing New York to begin enforcement in January 2025.
Findings of the Investigation
The OAG’s investigation, which spanned approximately 18 months, revealed that T-Mobile’s implementation of the ABA plans was significantly out of compliance with both the letter and the spirit of the law. According to the settlement documents, the company’s internal policies created a "de facto" barrier for the very demographic the law intended to support.
The most critical finding was the imposition of a 50 GB monthly data cap. While the ABA mandates a minimum speed of 25 Mbps, the state found that T-Mobile’s policy of throttling users to 600 Kbps once the cap was reached effectively rendered the service unusable for modern digital necessities. State officials noted in their public disclosure that an average user could hit the 50 GB threshold within four days of moderate usage, such as streaming high-definition video or participating in multiple video conferences.

Furthermore, investigators discovered that T-Mobile had restricted the availability of these plans exclusively to areas where it had already deployed 5G home Internet infrastructure. This exclusion effectively barred thousands of residents in rural and underserved areas—where the company still relies on 4G LTE technology—from accessing the mandated low-income plans, even though those same areas were served by T-Mobile’s full-priced, high-speed offerings.
Perhaps most egregious from a regulatory standpoint was the finding that T-Mobile had actively interfered with consumer discovery. The investigation determined that the company’s webpage dedicated to the ABA plans contained "noindex" tags, a technical setting that prevents search engines like Google from indexing the page. By hiding the program from search engine queries, T-Mobile made it nearly impossible for eligible New Yorkers to find information on how to enroll.
Chronology of Regulatory Action
The path to this settlement began in June 2025, when the New York Department of Public Service (DPS) identified irregularities in T-Mobile’s plan offerings. Upon referring these concerns to the Office of the Attorney General, a formal investigation was launched to determine the extent of the non-compliance.
- January 2025: New York begins formal enforcement of the Affordable Broadband Act following the Supreme Court’s refusal to hear the industry’s appeal.
- June 2025: The New York Department of Public Service notifies the OAG of potential violations regarding T-Mobile’s service restrictions.
- Late 2025 – Early 2026: The OAG conducts an inquiry, uncovering the 50 GB data cap, the 600 Kbps throttling policy, and the search engine indexing suppression.
- November 2026: The settlement is announced, requiring T-Mobile to remove all speed and data restrictions and provide full accessibility to the ABA plans within 120 days.
Official Responses and Corporate Strategy
T-Mobile has neither admitted nor denied the findings outlined in the settlement. In an official statement provided to media outlets, the company emphasized its commitment to connectivity while framing the resolution as a positive step forward.
"We have a long history of helping customers in New York stay connected through low-cost broadband, and we’re updating our plan to meet the state’s requirements while maintaining the same low price," a T-Mobile spokesperson stated. "We’ve reached an agreement with the New York attorney general that builds on that commitment, provides greater clarity around our offering, and makes the plan available to more eligible customers."
Governor Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James, however, framed the settlement as a victory for consumer rights. In a joint press release, the officials underscored the necessity of the Affordable Broadband Act in a post-pandemic world where reliable Internet is essential for education, employment, and healthcare. The OAG indicated that should T-Mobile fail to adhere to the terms of the settlement, the state is prepared to initiate litigation, which could result in civil penalties of up to $1,000 per violation.
Broader Implications for the Telecom Industry
This settlement highlights a growing tension between state-level consumer protections and the interests of major ISPs. While the Supreme Court’s inaction has solidified the legality of New York’s law, the industry remains hopeful that the federal government may intervene. Industry lobbyists are currently looking toward the incoming Trump administration, which has signaled a preference for pre-empting state-level broadband regulations, particularly for carriers that receive federal grants from the $42 billion Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program.

California is currently involved in a similar jurisdictional dispute with the federal government, asserting that state legislatures possess the inherent right to protect their citizens from predatory pricing and discriminatory service practices.
A Pattern of Regulatory Scrutiny
This incident marks the second time in recent months that T-Mobile has been forced to settle with New York state authorities over its service practices. In October 2026, the company reached a separate agreement to address violations of its "Price Guarantee" promises. The state investigation found that between 2017 and 2019, T-Mobile marketed plans with a "lifetime" price lock, only to raise rates by approximately $5 per month per line in 2024.
That agreement, valued at up to $38 million in customer benefits and reimbursements, combined with the current broadband settlement, suggests a tightening of the regulatory net around T-Mobile’s marketing and service policies in New York.
Moving Forward: What Consumers Can Expect
For New York residents, the settlement provides a clear pathway to better service. Within the next four months, T-Mobile is required to:
- Remove Data Caps: Eliminate the 50 GB monthly limit for all ABA-compliant plans.
- Unthrottle Speeds: Ensure that the 25 Mbps floor is maintained without arbitrary speed reductions.
- Expand Service Areas: Offer the plan in all areas where the company provides fixed wireless Internet, regardless of whether that connection is 4G or 5G.
- Improve Transparency: Remove technical blocks on its website to ensure the plans are easily discoverable via search engines and clearly linked from the company’s primary home Internet landing pages.
As the digital economy continues to evolve, the enforcement of the Affordable Broadband Act serves as a litmus test for how states can protect their most vulnerable populations. By forcing one of the nation’s largest carriers to remove artificial barriers to connectivity, New York has established a significant precedent for consumer-first Internet policy, signaling that affordability and accessibility are not merely suggestions, but non-negotiable legal requirements for providers operating within the state.






